Phlur's Heavy Cream vs Snif's Extra Whip: Best Creamy Gourmand Body Mists for Dessert Lovers 2025
Photo by: @cocoapixi
Have you ever walked past a bakery and wished you could bottle that feeling of pure comfort and sweetness? If so, you're in for a treat! As someone who's recently discovered the magical world of gourmand fragrances, I've been obsessed with finding scents that capture the essence of my favorite desserts without making me smell like I fell into a tub of cake batter.
Enter two creamy sensations that have been taking over my fragrance collection: Phlur's Heavy Cream and Snif's Extra Whip. Both promise that coveted "dessert in a bottle" experience, but they take completely different approaches to the art of smelling deliciously edible. After wearing these gourmand beauties for over a month, I'm here to break down everything you need to know about these creamy cloud body mists.
The Brands: Two Philosophies, One Delicious Goal
Phlur: The Gourmet Pastry Shop
Founded in 2015, Phlur approaches gourmand fragrances like a high-end pastry chef approaches dessert – sophisticated, intentional, and elevated. They're not trying to recreate the exact smell of your favorite treat; they're creating the *feeling* of indulgence with a grown-up twist.
Think of Phlur's Heavy Cream as that boutique bakery where everything looks almost too beautiful to eat. Their Heavy Cream isn't just cream – its artisanal vanilla bean ice cream served in a crystal bowl.
Snif: The Nostalgic Ice Cream Truck
Snif burst onto the scene in 2020 with a mission to make gourmand fragrances fun, approachable, and totally crave-worthy. They're the brand that gets that sometimes you just want to smell like the best dessert of your childhood, no awkward teen phase required!
Where Phlur whispers "sophisticated indulgence," Snif shouts "pure joy!" Their approach to creamy scents is all about capturing those perfect nostalgic moments; the first taste of soft-serve on a hot summer day, birthday cake frosting and that perfect whipped cream dollop. With price ranges from $22-$38USD, both have positioned themselves as an accessible luxury mist for fragrance lovers who want to add dessert sophistication to their current fragrance combination.
Scent Breakdown: The Art of Edible Elegance
photo by @cocoapixi
Phlur Heavy Cream: The Gourmet Experience
**Top Notes: ** Lemon Sugar, Marshmallow, Orange
**Heart Notes: ** Jasmine Blossom, Coconut Cream, Vegan Ambrettolide
**Base Notes: ** Vanilla Mousse, Salted Caramel, Whipped Cream
What really caught me off guard about Heavy Cream was the jasmine in the middle - I honestly wasn't expecting a floral note in something that smells like dessert! It keeps it from being too sweet or predictable, which I'm learning is apparently a good thing in fragrances. Too much floral is usually a no go for me, however this was a surprise I actually welcomed. The coconut cream is really nice - it gives off this tropical vibe without being too overpowering. The vanilla is where this really shines for me. It's not like basic vanilla extract - it's fluffier and more complex? And there's this salted caramel thing happening that I keep noticing throughout the day. I am new to this whole gourmand fragrance thing, but I can tell there's more going on here than just “smells like cookies.” This hits that sweet spot where you smell good without smelling like a teenager who dumped perfume all over themselves. It feels grown-up but still fun - like something you would wear on a really good date.
photo by @cocoapixi
Snif Extra Whip: The Pure Comfort Fantasy
**Top Notes: ** Aldehydes, Icing Sugar
**Heart Notes: ** Whipped Cream
**Base Notes: ** Vanilla, Sandalwood, Musk
Extra Whip takes a completely different approach to the creamy gourmand story. This is pure nostalgia bottled- the scent equivalent of your favorite childhood dessert memory but refined enough for your adult life. The opening hits you with this fizzy, almost sparkly feeling, like there's actual carbonation in the bottle. The sugar note is spot-on for cake frosting, sweet but not overwhelming in that artificial way some gourmands can be, which gives me a headache. The whipped cream note is where this really got me. It's so realistic and pillowy, like you could actually taste it. I keep catching whiffs of it throughout the day and it never gets old or annoying, which honestly surprised me since I thought it might be too much. There's something happening in the dry down that I'm still trying to figure out - it gets warmer as it settles. The sweetness stays but there's this underlying coziness that makes it feel more sophisticated than I expected. It's like the difference between eating dessert at home versus at a nice restaurant - same idea but elevated.
Performance: The Real Talk on Gourmand Longevity
Longevity and Sillage (shout out to Sephora for the new vocabulary!)
Heavy Cream delivers solid performance with 6-8 hours on my skin. The complex composition helps it evolve throughout the day, with different notes taking center stage as time passes. You'll catch whiffs of different dessert elements as it develops. Extra Whip gives me about 4-6 hours, which is actually perfect for a lighter gourmand. It stays close to the skin, creating an intimate dessert cloud that's perfect for everyday wear without overwhelming anyone in your vicinity.
Best Gourmand Layering Combinations Suggested by Friends
Heavy Cream + Vanilla Skin
I actually tried this combo since I own both, and the spicy warmth from Vanilla Skin makes Heavy Cream way more interesting. Instead of just smelling like dessert, you get this cozy, almost Christmas-cookie vibe. It's like when you add cinnamon to vanilla ice cream - still sweet but with more going on. Way more complex than either one alone. Both full size versions are packaged as a bestselling duo called Vanilla & Cream Duo for $66USD.
Heavy Cream + Missing Person
My friend Amaya suggested this pairing and I'm so curious to try it! She says the floral notes actually complement each other really well - you get jasmine from both but it creates this fancy dessert-with-flower-petals effect. Sounds like it would be perfect for when you want something sweet but not too heavy. Definitely adding Missing Person to my wishlist.
Extra Whip + Spray Tan
Someone on my Tiktok recommended this combo and I'm obsessed with the idea. Apparently, the coconut makes the whipped cream smell even more tropical and summery, like eating ice cream on the beach. Pure vacation vibes. I might have to grab Spray Tan just to try this.
Extra Whip + Me
My friend Amaya also recommended this and she swears by this combination! She says the caramel in Me goes perfectly with Extra Whip's cake frosting vibe, and the fruit notes keep it from being too much sugar. Like strawberries and cream but fancier. This combo actually has me wanting to understand layering better - apparently you get something completely new that's better than the originals, which lead to endless combinations!
Price Breakdown: The Sweetest Investment
**Phlur Heavy Cream: **
- Travel: $25USD/ 3.0oz
- Full size: $38/ 8.0oz
**Snif Extra Whip: **
- Travel: $22USD/ 2.5oz
- Full size: $34USD/ 8.0oz
For gourmand lovers, both offer excellent value. Extra Whip edges out on pure price, but Heavy Cream's superior longevity and complexity might make it more cost-effective per wear. Think of it as choosing between artisanal ice cream and premium soft-serve – both delicious, different price points.
The Dessert Occasions: When to Wear Your Gourmand
Heavy Cream Is Perfect For:
- Date nights when you want to smell expensively edible
- Cozy autumn and winter days when you crave comfort
- Special occasions that call for sophisticated sweetness
- Layering with other gourmands for complex dessert vibes
Extra Whip Shines During:
- Everyday wear when you want subtle sweetness
- Spring and summer when heavy gourmands feel too much
- Casual dates and friend hangouts
- Work environments (it's sweet but professional)
The Verdict: Building Your Gourmand Collection
Here's the beautiful thing about gourmand fragrances – they're not just scents, they're experiences. Heavy Cream and Extra Whip prove that creamy, dessert-inspired fragrances can be sophisticated, wearable, and absolutely addictive.
You need Heavy Cream if: You want a signature gourmand that feels intentional and complex. You love scents that evolve throughout the day. You are building a curated fragrance wardrobe focused on sophisticated sweetness.
You need Extra Whip if: You want an everyday gourmand that feels effortless and comforting. You prefer lighter scents that don't overwhelm. You are new to gourmand fragrances and want something universally appealing.
You need both if: You understand that different moods call for different desserts. At under $90 for both travel sizes, it's an affordable way to explore two completely different approaches to creamy gourmand fragrance.
Gourmand Beginner Tips
1. Start with travel sizes– Perfect for testing how gourmands work with your skin
2. Apply sparingly – Gourmands can be potent; less is often more when layering with other perfumes
3. Consider the weather – Heavy gourmands for cool weather, light ones for warmth
4.Layer strategically – Matching body products can enhance longevity
Final Thoughts: Your Dessert Fragrance Journey
As someone discovering the magical world of gourmand fragrances, these two scents have shown me that smelling like dessert doesn't have to mean sacrificing sophistication. Whether you choose Heavy Cream's gourmet complexity or Extra Whip's nostalgic comfort (or both, like this newly converted gourmand addict), you are investing in scents that will make every day feel a little sweeter.
The real question isn't which one smells better – it is which dessert experience calls to you today. Some days demand Heavy Cream's confident indulgence, others need Extra Whip's gentle comfort. Both deserve a place in any gourmand lover's collection.
Which creamy gourmand is calling your name? Let me know if you're team sophisticated dessert or team nostalgic comfort – and don't forget to save this for your next fragrance shopping adventure!